Court Rules
All enforcement actions
SettlementMedium Risk

Colorado AG settles with Avail Property Management and PK Management over illegal tenant screening practices

Avail Property Management Inc. and PK Management, LLCSeptember 2, 2026Colorado Attorney General

Penalty Amount

$300,000

Summary

Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser announced a settlement with Avail Property Management Inc. and PK Management, LLC resolving allegations that the companies denied prospective tenants housing based on criminal history information prohibited under Colorado's Rental Application Fairness Act, including arrests, deferred judgments, and convictions older than five years (some more than 20 years old). The companies, which managed nearly 4,000 rental units across Colorado, relied on a third-party background screening service despite legal prohibitions. Under the settlement, they must change screening practices, review vendor recommendations rather than relying on them automatically, submit to two years of compliance reporting, and pay $300,000.

Remedy

Under the stipulated consent judgment (subject to court approval), Avail and PK must comply with the Rental Application Fairness Act's prohibition on considering criminal convictions older than five years except where Colorado law expressly allows, stop considering arrests, pending charges, and other non-conviction records, revise tenant screening policies and consumer-facing materials, review third-party background screening recommendations instead of automatically relying on screening vendors, submit documentation demonstrating compliance and provide annual compliance reports to the Attorney General's Office for two years, and pay $300,000 for attorney's fees, consumer fraud and antitrust enforcement, and consumer education.

Monetary PenaltyInjunctionConsent DecreeCompliance ProgramReporting Requirements

Contract Impact

Property management companies, landlords, and any business relying on background checks should review their agreements with third-party background screening vendors (consumer reporting agencies) to ensure screening reports comply with state-law limits on criminal history use — specifically filtering out arrests, pending charges, deferred judgments, and convictions older than five years where required — and should add warranties and indemnification provisions holding the vendor accountable for reports configured in violation of state screening laws. Contracts should prohibit automatic reliance on vendor recommendations and require human review of screening results. Teams should also audit lease application forms, adverse action notices, and consumer-facing disclosures for compliance with laws like Colorado's Rental Application Fairness Act, and build annual compliance reporting/certification obligations into vendor and operating agreements.

Contract Search Terms

tenant screeningcriminal historyRental Application Fairness Actbackground check vendorthird-party screening serviceadverse action noticearrest recordsconviction lookback periodconsumer-facing materialscompliance reporting

Laws Cited

Colorado Rental Application Fairness ActColorado Consumer Protection Act

Violation Types

Entity Details

Entity

Avail Property Management Inc. and PK Management, LLC

Industry

Real Estate

Official Sources

Source Evidence

Entity Name
"a settlement with Avail Property Management Inc. and PK Management, LLC resolving allegations"
Fine Amount
"Pay $300,000 for attorney’s fees, consumer fraud and antitrust enforcement, and consumer education."
Laws Cited
"the companies violated Colorado’s Rental Application Fairness Act and the Colorado Consumer Protection Act by using prohibited criminal history information to deny housing to prospective tenants"
Violation Types
"applicants were denied housing based on arrests, deferred judgments, and convictions that occurred more than five years before they applied, including some convictions that were more than 20 years old."
Remedy Types
"Review third-party background screening recommendations instead of automatically relying on screening vendors."
Remedy Summary
"provide annual compliance reports to the Attorney General’s Office for two years."

Related Enforcement Actions

CO

National Highway Traffic Safety Administration

Colorado joined a coalition of states and local governments in suing the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration over its rule weakening fuel economy standards for new passenger cars and light trucks. The coalition alleges the rule violates federal law; the press release does not report a penalty or a court ruling.

CO

United States Environmental Protection Agency

Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser joined a multistate and local coalition challenging the EPA’s repeal of greenhouse gas limits for many coal- and gas-fired power plants. The coalition seeks to have the repeal struck down and the protections restored, and separately notified the EPA of its intent to sue over regulation of emissions from existing gas plants; no penalty or final court remedy is reported.

CO

Sandoz Inc. and Fougera Pharmaceuticals Inc.

$469.0M

Colorado joined a 43-state-and-territory settlement resolving allegations that Sandoz and Fougera participated in a long-running conspiracy to inflate generic drug prices, reduce competition, and restrain trade. The companies agreed to pay approximately $469 million and implement reforms; the states are seeking court approval.

CO

Corteva, Inc.

$35.0M

Colorado, the FTC, and a coalition of state attorneys general reached a settlement with Corteva over allegations that its post-patent loyalty program restricted distributors from selling competing generic pesticides. Corteva must end the challenged conduct and pay the states $35 million for fees and costs; the agreement is in effect for 10 years.

CO

Laboratory Corporation of America

$2.3M

Colorado and a bipartisan coalition of attorneys general reached a $2,287,455 settlement with Laboratory Corporation of America over the 2019 data breach at its debt collector, American Medical Collection Agency. The settlement requires stronger vendor risk management and information security practices, with particular requirements for medical debt collectors.

CO

Paramount Skydance Corporation

Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser joined a coalition of 12 attorneys general in settling a lawsuit against Paramount Skydance Corporation over its merger with Warner Bros. Discovery, which the states alleged would harm competition by lowering film output and raising prices. The settlement includes a five-year commitment to increase film output, a $1.5 billion investment in domestic production, a $47.5 million worker fund, and an independent monitor. This is an antitrust/competition enforcement action, not a privacy enforcement action, despite the extraction schema's privacy focus.