Court Rules
All enforcement actions
Enforcement ActionLow Risk

FTC Removes Aristotle from COPPA Safe Harbor Program

Aristotle International, Inc.August 4, 2021Federal Trade Commission

Summary

The FTC removed Aristotle International, Inc. from its list of approved COPPA Safe Harbor programs due to insufficient monitoring of member companies' compliance with COPPA guidelines. This action prevents operators from using Aristotle's program for favorable regulatory treatment and marks the first such removal since COPPA's inception.

Remedy

Aristotle was banned from the FTC's COPPA Safe Harbor program, meaning it can no longer certify companies for compliance and operators lose the benefits of its oversight.

Ban

Contract Impact

In-house legal teams should review all vendor and customer agreements where a party represents compliance with children's privacy laws through an FTC-approved Safe Harbor program, particularly those referencing Aristotle International or similar self-regulatory organizations. Specific clauses to scrutinize include: (1) representations and warranties regarding COPPA compliance and Safe Harbor participation; (2) monitoring, audit, and enforcement obligations of the self-regulatory organization; (3) termination rights triggered if a Safe Harbor program loses FTC approval; and (4) indemnification provisions related to privacy violations. Agreements may need amendments to require alternative compliance methods (e.g., direct adherence to COPPA) and to add notification obligations if a designated Safe Harbor program is delisted. Employee agreements involving data handling of children's information should also be assessed for alignment with direct COPPA requirements.

Contract Search Terms

Safe Harbor programCOPPA compliance certificationthird-party monitoringself-regulatory organizationchildren's privacy programregulatory safe harborcompliance audit rightscertification benefits

Laws Cited

COPPACOPPA Rule

Violation Types

Entity Details

Entity

Aristotle International, Inc.

Also known as: Aristotle

Industry

Other

Official Sources

Source Evidence

Entity Name
"Aristotle International, Inc. (Aristotle)"
Laws Cited
"Children’s Online Privacy Protection Act (COPPA)"
Laws Cited
"COPPA Rule"
Violation Types
"may not have sufficiently monitored its member companies to ensure they were complying with its guidelines, as required by the COPPA Rule."

Related Enforcement Actions

FTC

Lens.com Inc.

The FTC, Utah, and Nevada sued Lens.com Inc., alleging that it advertised artificially low contact lens prices while hiding mandatory checkout charges and misleading consumers about its AutoRefill subscription. The complaint seeks to stop the alleged practices; the court has not yet decided the case, and no penalty or remedy has been imposed.

FTC

Online platforms

The FTC issued an advance notice of proposed rulemaking seeking public comment on whether ad-optimization tools offered by online platforms may help scammers impersonate businesses and government agencies. This is a proposed regulatory inquiry, not an enforcement action against a named company; no penalty or remedy was imposed.

FTC

Amazon.com, Inc.

$2.5B

A federal court approved a revised order in the FTC's Amazon Prime case under which Amazon will accelerate and expand redress payments under the September 2025 $2.5 billion settlement, which resolved allegations that Amazon enrolled millions of consumers in Prime subscriptions without their consent and knowingly made cancellation difficult. More consumers now qualify for refunds, the maximum payment cap rises from $51 to $200, and all future payments will be distributed automatically starting October 1, 2026, with potential supplemental $149 payments by April 2027. Amazon has already issued more than $845 million in redress payments as of September 2026.

FTC

Amway Corp.

$225.0M

The FTC and the state of Washington filed a joint complaint and proposed stipulated order requiring Amway Corp. and two affiliates—World Wide Group, L.L.C. (WWG) and Leadership Team Development Inc. (LTD)—to pay a $225 million judgment, the largest monetary recovery ever obtained from an MLM in an FTC action, over allegations that they used deceptive earnings claims and unfair tactics to recruit Independent Business Owners. The complaint alleges the companies falsely promised substantial income and recruitment success, pressured IBOs to buy products they could not resell, and instructed IBOs to falsely report sales. Nearly all of the judgment will be used as redress for IBOs who lost money, and the proposed order imposes structural reforms including a 70% resale requirement, independent audits of sales records, and a ban on approved providers charging new IBOs for first-year training.

FTC

FleetCor Technologies Inc. (now Corpay Inc.)

$100.0M

FleetCor Technologies Inc. (now Corpay Inc.) and its CEO Ronald Clarke agreed to pay $100 million to settle an FTC administrative action alleging the company charged small business customers hidden and unauthorized fees for fuel cards and misrepresented gas savings, fraud-control features, and fees. A federal district court granted the FTC summary judgment on all counts in 2023, and a federal appeals court upheld that judgment and the permanent injunction in 2026. The settlement funds will be used to provide redress to harmed business customers.

FTC

Automobile industry (auto dealers) - no named respondent; industry-wide guidance publication

FTC staff published FAQs on price transparency to help the automobile industry comply with the FTC Act, reiterating that an advertised vehicle price must be the actual price any consumer can pay, excluding only government-required charges. The guidance follows warning letters the FTC sent to 97 auto dealership groups earlier in 2026 and signals continued litigation against dealers that advertise one price but charge more through undisclosed fees. No specific entity was charged and no penalty was imposed.